Best NYC Gifts & Experience Gifts: 2025 Edition
Skip the ordinary and gift the extraordinary! New York - City Style merch + unforgettable experience gifts, local NYC area-made treats, and indie accessories. Quick ideas, instant options, and budget picks below.
Experience Gifts & Things To Do in the NYC Area (E-gift friendly)
| Name | What it is | Shop |
|---|
| The Met | Museum—tickets & membership | Shop Now |
| MoMA | Museum—tickets, membership & store | Shop Now |
| American Museum of Natural History | Museum—tickets & membership | Shop Now |
| New York Botanical Garden | Garden—admission & membership | Shop Now |
| Brooklyn Museum | Exhibitions & membership | Shop Now |
| Carnegie Hall | Concerts & digital gift cards | Shop Now |
| New York City Ballet | Performances & subscriptions | Shop Now |
| The Public Theater | Plays & programs (Shakespeare in the Park) | Shop Now |
| Lincoln Center | Performing arts campus—tickets & memberships | Shop Now |
| The Shed | Contemporary arts—tickets & support | Shop Now |
| New York CityPASS | Mobile bundle tickets | Shop Now |
| Go City: New York | All-Inclusive & Explorer passes | Shop Now |
NYC Area-Made Food & Beverage Gifts
| Name | What it is | Shop |
|---|
| Russ & Daughters | Appetizing classics & gift boxes | Shop Now |
| Zabar’s | NYC deli favorites | Shop Now |
| Economy Candy | Old-school sweets & treats | Shop Now |
| Levain Bakery | Famous cookies shipped nationwide | Shop Now |
| Jacques Torres Chocolate | NYC chocolatier | Shop Now |
| Di Palo’s | Italian provisions & gifts | Shop Now |
| Joe Coffee Company | NYC roaster—beans & e-gifts | Shop Now |
| Sahadi’s | Middle Eastern pantry & gifts | Shop Now |
OTL & NYC City Style
| Name | What it is | Shop |
|---|
| City Style: Collection |
Tees, hoodies, caps & mugs |
Shop Now |
| OTL Seat Fillers (NYC) |
Join for local shows & experiences |
Shop Now |
| Gift an OTL Membership (NYC) |
Instant e-gift delivery |
Shop Now |
| Things To Do in NYC |
Plays, comedy, concerts, festivals |
Shop Now |
Accessories & Home Gifts (NYC Area Makers)
| Name | What it is | Shop |
|---|
| Catbird | Brooklyn jewelry & gift cards | Shop Now |
| Fishs Eddy | Quirky NYC dishware & gifts | Shop Now |
| MoMA Design Store | Design-led gifts | Shop Now |
| Strand Book Store | Books, totes & gift cards | Shop Now |
| New York Transit Museum Store | Transit-themed prints & toys | Shop Now |
| Artists & Fleas | Local makers market | Shop Now |
Food Hall & Market Gift Cards
| Name | What it is | Shop |
|---|
| Chelsea Market | Iconic market & eateries | Shop Now |
| Time Out Market New York | DUMBO food hall | Shop Now |
| Essex Market | Lower East Side market | Shop Now |
| Urbanspace (Vanderbilt & more) | Food halls & seasonal markets | Shop Now |
| Turnstyle Underground Market | Columbus Circle underground mall | Shop Now |
| The Market Line | Lower East Side food & retail | Shop Now |
Last Minute Digital Gifts (Instant Delivery!)
| Name | What it is | Shop |
|---|
| Gift an OTL Membership (NYC) | Instant e-gift | Shop Now |
| SeatFillerShop | eGift card (merch or seat filling) | Shop Now |
| TodayTix | Digital theatre gift cards | Shop Now |
| Ticketmaster | eGift card for concerts & comedy | Shop Now |
| Go City: New York | Mobile attraction passes | Shop Now |
| New York CityPASS | Mobile bundle tickets | Shop Now |
| MoMA | Join or gift membership online | Shop Now |
| The Met | Purchase memberships online | Shop Now |
Budget-Friendly Picks (Under $50)
| Name | What it is | Shop |
|---|
| Economy Candy | Sweet sampler boxes & $10–$25 gifts | Shop Now |
| Levain Bakery | Cookie 4-packs & gift cards | Shop Now |
| Fishs Eddy | NYC dish towels & mugs under $25 | Shop Now |
| Joe Coffee Company | 12oz beans or $25 e-gift | Shop Now |
| The Sill | Small potted plants (~$38+) | Shop Now |
| New York Transit Museum Store | Metro-themed pins, socks & toys | Shop Now |
| Strand Book Store | Iconic totes & $25 gift cards | Shop Now |
| Doughnut Plant | Gift cards & merch | Shop Now |
Need a Gift Right Now?
Grab an instant e-gift or pick a local favorite—done in minutes.
